Clinical trial disruption due to Covid-19 has begun to decline

GlobalData Healthcare 9th July 2020 (Last Updated July 9th, 2020 14:11)

Clinical trial disruption due to Covid-19 has begun to decline

Since early March, around 1,000 organisations supporting clinical trials as the sponsor, collaborator, or contract research organisation (CRO) have publically announced disruptions to planned and ongoing clinical trials in their press releases, Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filings, and clinical trial registries, as well as on social media. Companies have delayed the initiation of planned trials or withdrawn these completely, as well as suspended enrolment in ongoing trials or terminated these trials. GlobalData dynamically tracks these disrupted trials and organisations, along with trials that have resumed activity since disruption.

After three months of increasing clinical trial disruptions, within the last month, the number has begun to fall between June and July (Figure 1). The majority of clinical trial disruption currently was due to the suspension of enrolment, followed by trials impacted due to slow enrolment, and then finally, trials that have delayed initiation. Although the total number of disrupted trials is decreasing overall, within these categories only trials that suspended enrolment have gone down 17.3%, compared to last month, whereas clinical trials that delayed initiation have gone up 10% and trials that have been impacted by slow enrolment have gone up by 13.9% (Table 1). This suggests trials that had already initiated enrolment before the pandemic, with chosen sites and investigators, but then suspended due to Covid-19, are having more success picking up where they left off as long as enrolment wasn’t impacted. Within the category of trials affected by slow enrolment, one-tenth of these are specifically due to the availability of sites and investigators. Many hospitals that serve as trial sites were inundated with Covid-19 patients and may still not be available. For that same reason, many investigators may be repurposed to Covid-19 drug discovery trials or treating Covid-19 patients, or activation of sites for non-Covid-19 trials are being deprioritised. As the number of trials that have been impacted by slow enrolment has increased by 13.9%, this seems to continue to be an issue. Trials that have delayed initiation altogether have also increased by 10% compared to last month. Besides the issue just mentioned, there is also a high risk to subjects in a clinical trial who have a serious chronic or acute condition that affects their immune system, giving them a greater chance of contracting Covid-19 and making them not willing to enrol in a clinical trial.

The overwhelming majority of trial sites that are currently disrupted are located in the US, at 42.4%. This is followed by the UK at 7.2% of all sites and Spain at 4.7%. The US is currently seeing the highest number of confirmed Covid-19 cases since the pandemic began to spike in certain states such as Florida, California, Arizona, and Texas. The highest numbers of site disruptions are found in California at 10.8%, followed by Florida at 10.3% and Texas at 9.5%. New York comes in fourth at 6.1%, where the pandemic initially hit the hardest.

The FDA has issued guidance for industry, investigators, and institutional review boards on conducting clinical trials during the Covid-19 pandemic. Methods that could help keep the research going or get started include virtual visits, phone interviews, self-administration, and remote monitoring. These suggestions could help trials that are being met with subject quarantine and travel limitations, clinical site closures, and interrupted supply chains, especially trials that delayed initiation and trials that have been impacted by slow enrolment. Importantly, the total number of disrupted trials is falling and the number of clinical trials that have resumed has almost doubled since last month. This implies that sponsors and contract service providers have begun to adjust clinical trial design strategies and are adapting to the new post-Covid-19 environment.